The Uncertainty Principle and What It Really Limits

heisenberg uncertainty principle

Does the Heisenberg uncertainty principle mean that merely looking at a particle disturbs it? Not quite. It caps how small the quantum fluctuations of position and momentum can both be; disturbance by measurement is a separate, related claim.

This page is one part of our wider guide to quantum mechanics.

Item Value
Heisenberg’s error-disturbance version Proposed in 1927 via a gamma-ray microscope thought experiment; ε(q)η(p) ≥ h/4π
Kennard’s fluctuation version Derived in 1927; σ(q)σ(p) ≥ h/4π
Ozawa’s error-disturbance relation Developed in 2003 at Nagoya University
Hasegawa team’s experiment Neutrons, two spin components measured, at the Vienna University of Technology
Nature Physics report Published January 15; covered by Scientific American on March 8, 2012

The figures above come from Scientific American’s March 2012 report. Research moves on, so check the source before you rely on them.

What the Heisenberg uncertainty principle says

The principle holds that we cannot know the present state of the world in full detail, let alone predict the future with absolute precision, as Scientific American put it. It marks a clear break from the classical, deterministic view of the universe.

The trouble starts with the name. The same report says the uncertainty principle comes in two superficially similar formulations that even many practicing physicists tend to confuse.

Two formulations that are easy to confuse

Both versions were written down in 1927, and both end in the same bound, h/4π. They describe different things, though.

  • Heisenberg’s version is about measurement: observing the world inevitably disturbs it.
  • Kennard’s version is about fluctuations: position and momentum cannot both be sharply defined at the same time.

Mixing them up gives the popular slogan that “looking changes the thing.” That slogan fits only the first version, and the report calls that version wrong.

heisenberg uncertainty principle Green trails
Bright green light trails sweep horizontally across a dark background.

Heisenberg’s gamma-ray microscope and the error-disturbance claim

Heisenberg inferred his formulation in 1927 through a thought experiment in which he imagined measuring the position of an electron with a gamma-ray microscope. The formula he derived was ε(q)η(p) ≥ h/4π, according to Scientific American.

Here ε(q) is the error in a position measurement and η(p) is the disturbance it causes to momentum. The inequality says you cannot help but alter the electron’s momentum when you measure its position. An experimenter must make a tradeoff.

Heisenberg drew a wide conclusion from this: everything observed is a selection from a plenitude of possibilities and a limitation on what is possible in the future. That is a philosophical reading of the formula, not a separate result.

Kennard’s version: the one physicists use

The same year, Earle Kennard derived a different formulation, later generalized by Howard Robertson: σ(q)σ(p) ≥ h/4π. In plain terms, you cannot suppress the quantum fluctuations of both position and momentum below a certain limit at once, the report explains.

Four points set it apart from Heisenberg’s version:

  • The fluctuation exists whether or not anyone measures it.
  • The inequality says nothing about what happens during a measurement.
  • It is the version physicists use in everyday research, even though they call it Heisenberg’s.
  • If experiments violated it, the whole of quantum mechanics would break down.

Heisenberg’s formulation was proposed as a conjecture, so quantum mechanics is not shaken when it fails.

How a neutron experiment tested the error-disturbance claim

In 2003, Masanao Ozawa of Nagoya University developed a new formulation of the error-disturbance uncertainty Heisenberg had aimed to express, this time on firmer footing. It adds fluctuation terms: ε(q)η(p) + σ(q)η(p) + σ(p)ε(q) ≥ h/4π, as Scientific American reported.

A team led by Yuji Hasegawa at the Vienna University of Technology put it to the test. They prepared a stream of neutrons and measured two spin components simultaneously for each one. That directly violated Heisenberg’s version, yet Ozawa’s relation continued to hold.

The team reported its results in Nature Physics on January 15. As of the March 2012 report, Hasegawa’s team was the first to demonstrate both the violation of Heisenberg’s inequality and the validity of Ozawa’s.

What the result showed

  • Even when the source of error or the disturbance is held to nearly zero, the other remains finite.
  • Errors and disturbances are clearly separated from quantum fluctuations.
  • Physicist Shogo Tanimura noted that errors can be reduced by letting the object system have larger fluctuations, “although it may sound contradictory.”

The report concludes that the error-disturbance relation is no longer just a conjecture but physical law.

What the principle does and does not limit

It does limit how sharply position and momentum can both be defined. It does not say that every act of observation must disturb a system by a fixed amount.

  • It limits the joint fluctuations of position and momentum.
  • In Ozawa’s form, it limits the trade between measurement error and disturbance.
  • It does not make the original microscope argument a general rule about observation.

For the wave picture behind these limits, see our explainer on wave-particle duality. For another way quantum systems defy classical intuition, read about quantum entanglement.

Frequently asked questions

Is the uncertainty principle just about measurement disturbance?

Show answer

No. The version physicists use in everyday research, Kennard’s, is about fluctuations that exist whether or not they are measured. The measurement-disturbance idea is Heisenberg’s original version.

Who derived the version physicists actually use?

Show answer

Earle Kennard derived it in 1927, and Howard Robertson later generalized it. Physicists call it Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle anyway.

Was Heisenberg’s original inequality violated?

Show answer

Yes, according to Scientific American’s March 2012 report. A Vienna University of Technology team measured two neutron spin components together in violation of it, while Ozawa’s relation held.

Would a violation break quantum mechanics?

Show answer

It depends on the version. Violating Kennard’s would break the whole of quantum mechanics, but Heisenberg’s was a conjecture, so its violation does not shake the theory.