Wondering how two particles can stay linked even when far apart? Quantum entanglement is a state in which particles share correlations stronger than classical physics allows, and experiments honoured by the 2022 Nobel Prize confirmed it.
Entanglement is one idea inside quantum mechanics, and the sections below follow how experiments put it to the test.
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| 2022 Nobel Prize in Physics laureates | Alain Aspect, John Clauser and Anton Zeilinger |
| Value of the prize | 10 million kronor ($900,000) |
| Year Bell showed hidden variables could be tested | 1964 |
| First Bell test experiment (Clauser) | 1972 |
| Improved test by Aspect and colleagues | 1982 |
| Locality loophole closed (Zeilinger and colleagues) | 1998 |
These figures come from Physics World and Scientific American. Reports can be updated, so check the sources before you rely on the figures.
What quantum entanglement means
In an entangled pair, the particles behave like a single unit even when they are separated, as the University of Rostock’s physics institute put it when the Nobel Prize was announced. What happens to one particle determines what happens to the other, even if they are far apart.
The Physics World report calls this a curious effect, in which particles show much stronger correlations than are possible in classical physics. The word “correlation” simply means that the measured results of the particles line up more tightly than any ordinary link could explain.
Popular accounts often describe an action on one particle as rippling instantly through the whole entangled set. Scientific American used that language in its report of 4 October 2022, and it added that what fundamentally occurs during a measurement is still a topic of intense debate among scientists.
Why Einstein called it spooky
According to Scientific American, the effect seemed so counterintuitive that Albert Einstein once derided it as “spooky action at a distance”. Einstein believed that objects, whether planets or particles, possess fundamental properties that precise observation can discern.
On that view, hidden variables would preordain the states of widely separated particles before they were measured. The particles would then match each other without information travelling between them faster than light.
Niels Bohr, Erwin Schrödinger and others disagreed. In the same report’s words, they held that reality is inherently fuzzy and that particles only gain certain specific characteristics upon being measured.
The thought experiment that carries Schrödinger’s name is covered in the explainer on schrodinger’s cat. For another idea about what measurement can and cannot reveal, read the explainer on the heisenberg uncertainty principle.
How Bell’s inequality turned a debate into a test
As Scientific American explains, in 1964 John Stewart Bell showed that the presence of hidden variables could be inferred experimentally, by carefully measuring many pairs of entangled particles. The idea turned a philosophical argument into something a laboratory could check.
The Rostock summary states the logic simply. If hidden variables exist, the correlation across a large number of measurements will never exceed a certain value, yet quantum mechanics predicts that a certain type of experiment will exceed it.

Early tests had gaps. Physics World describes a detection loophole, where the photons detected might not be a fair sample of those emitted, and a locality loophole, where parts of the setup thought to be independent might be causally connected.
Bell himself did not share in the prize. Physics World notes that he died in 1990 and that Nobel prizes are not awarded posthumously.
The experiments that settled the question
Three research efforts, each building on the last, carried the test from idea to a result most physicists accept:
- Clauser, 1972. Scientific American says he conceived a practical Bell test in 1969, and Physics World reports that the first experiment was done in 1972 at the University of California at Berkeley. It measured polarization correlations between photon pairs and found Bell’s inequality violated, though loopholes made it inconclusive.
- Aspect, 1982. Physics World reports that Aspect and colleagues in Orsay, France, used a two-channel detection scheme and varied the orientation of the polarizing filters. The Rostock summary adds that the settings could be switched after a pair had left its source.
- Zeilinger, 1998. Physics World says his group at the University of Innsbruck closed the locality loophole, using two fully independent quantum random-number generators to set the measurement directions.
- Four groups, 2015. As of Scientific American’s 4 October 2022 report, the last major loophole for Bell tests was closed in 2015 through the work of four different research groups.
The 2022 Nobel Prize went to Aspect, Clauser and Zeilinger “for their experiments with entangled photons, establishing the violation of Bell’s inequalities and pioneering quantum information science”, according to Physics World. The prize is worth 10 million kronor ($900,000) and was shared equally.
The Rostock summary draws the conclusion that quantum mechanics cannot be replaced by a theory that uses hidden variables. That is the sense in which Einstein’s preferred picture lost out.
What is entanglement used for?
Anders Irbäck, Chair of the Nobel Committee for Physics, said it has become increasingly clear that a new kind of quantum technology is emerging, according to the Rostock summary. The same source lists the research areas that now draw on entanglement:
- Quantum computers, which Physics World says could in principle outperform conventional computers at some tasks.
- Quantum networks.
- Secure quantum encrypted communication.
Quantum teleportation is another example. Scientific American reports that Zeilinger’s group and a team led by Francesco De Martini independently demonstrated it in 1997, and that it has become central to efforts to build a quantum internet.
The same report refers to China’s Micius spacecraft as the first quantum communications satellite. These are active research areas, so treat any claim about near-term products with caution.
Frequently asked questions
Was Einstein wrong about hidden variables?
Show answer
The Rostock summary says Clauser’s measurements violated a Bell inequality, which means quantum mechanics cannot be replaced by a theory that uses hidden variables. Debate continues over what happens during a measurement.
Who won the Nobel Prize for entanglement experiments?
Show answer
Alain Aspect, John Clauser and Anton Zeilinger won the 2022 Nobel Prize for Physics, according to Physics World. The same report says the prize would be shared equally between the winners.
What is a Bell test?
Show answer
It is an experiment that measures correlations between entangled particles to check whether they exceed what hidden variables could produce. Scientific American traces the idea to Bell’s work in 1964.
What is quantum teleportation?
Show answer
Per the Rostock summary, it makes it possible to move a quantum state from one particle to one at a distance. It relies on entanglement.



